By Harris Carney

Homemade Cooking: How To Make Deviled Eggs With Mayo And Mustard

Want to know how to make deviled eggs with mayo and mustard? We've got you covered with this easy recipe that's perfect for any party or potluck.

Deviled eggs are a classic appetizer that is always popular. This recipe for deviled eggs with mayo and mustard is simple, and the sauce makes them extra delicious. So next time you're searching for something quick and delicious, try this recipe!

Deviled Eggs

Deviled eggs are a savory dish made of hard-boiled eggs that have been sliced in half and filled with a creamy, seasoned filling. The name "deviled" refers to the spicy seasonings used in the egg filling, such as mustard, chile peppers, vinegar, or cayenne pepper. These flavorful ingredients give deviled eggs a zesty flavor that many people enjoy.


Deviled eggs can be served either hot or cold. When prepared cold, they often appear at picnics, potlucks, and other casual gatherings where high-quality finger food is needed. They can also be served as part of an appetizer spread or accompanied by a salad at dinner. When cooked hot, deviled eggs are great as a lunch or dinner main course. They can also be paired with various sides such as crackers, breadsticks, French fries, or crudité platters for a complete meal.

Because deviled eggs are so effortless to make and delicious to eat, they have become a favorite among house chefs and professional culinarians alike. So whether you're looking for something easy for your next family gathering or craving a satisfying snack on the go, deviled eggs are always sure to hit the spot.

Ingredients Needed

The eggs can be made with these basic and complimentary ingredients,

  • Six large eggs
  • 3 to 4 tablespoons mayonnaise
  • 1/2 teaspoon prepared mustard
  • 1/4 teaspoon salt or seasoned salt blend
  • Two teaspoons of finely chopped fresh parsley
  • 1/8 teaspoon ground black pepper, or to taste
  • 1/4 teaspoon ground paprika, or to taste

Steps To Make Perfect Deviled Eggs

Here are a few steps to make the perfect deviled eggs

Hard Boil Eggs

There are a few different ways to hard-boil eggs. The most common way is to place the eggs in a pot of cold water, get the boiled water, turn off the flame and allow the eggs to sit in the sizzling water for 10 to 12 minutes. You can also hard-boil eggs in an oven or on the stove. Whichever procedure you prefer, place the eggs in a single layer and ensure that the water or cooking liquid covers them completely.

Peel And Chill

Once the eggs have been boiled, the next thing to do is peel them and place them in the fridge overnight. This will allow the yolk mixture to cool and thicken, quickly making deviled egg yolk pipe into the egg whites.

Slice The Eggs

Cut the peeled eggs in half lengthwise once they have cooled. Place the egg white halves on a serving tray after removing the yolks and adding them to a medium bowl. The yolk mixture can be piped or spooned into the egg whites.

Prepare Deviled Egg Filling

What do you want to fill your egg with? This step is your choice; you can make any filling mixture to pour in the egg, along with mayo and mustard.

Mix mayonnaise, mustard, salt, parsley, and black pepper in a medium bowl until smooth. If you want your deviled eggs to be extra spicy, you can add a little more cayenne pepper or other hot sauce.

Fill The Egg

Use a cookie scoop or spoon to distribute the egg yolk filling into the egg whites evenly. Add a topping of your choice for the finishing touch. Now sprinkle with paprika and serve.

Tips For Hard Boil Eggs

Hard-boiled eggs can be tricky to get just right, with many factors influencing the final result. To ensure that your hard-boiled eggs turn out perfectly every time, it is essential to follow these simple tips:

Use Wider Saucepan

First, use a wider saucepan when boiling the eggs. This will allow them to cook evenly and prevent sticking to the pot's bottom.

Use Cold Water

Second, add cold water to the saucepan before heating. This will help keep your eggs from cracking while they boil.

Cover The Pan

Third, cover the pan while cooking to retain heat and reduce evaporation. This will also help prevent spills if your pan tips or wobbles during cooking.

Plunge Into Cold After Cooking

Finally, once your hard-boiled eggs are finished cooking, plunge them into a bowl of cold water for a few minutes to cease the cooking process and make them easier to peel. With these simple tips in mind, you can be sure that your hard-boiled eggs will always turn out perfectly every time!

Different Variations

Numerous variations of this traditional recipe for deviled eggs can use different garnishes or additions.


There are endless possibilities for toppings when making mayo and mustard-deviled eggs. Some popular options include:

Spicy Relish

For a tasty and spicy twist on traditional deviled eggs, try topping them with a dollop of spicy relish. This tangy condiment combines chopped onions, peppers, and other flavorful ingredients, making it the perfect finishing touch for these classic appetizers.

Bacon Bits

A classic topping for potato salad, bacon bits are also great for mayo and mustard deviled eggs. Not only do they add a savory flavor and pleasing crunch to these tasty snacks, but they also help to balance out the creamy egg yolk filling.

Dijon Mustard

Want to spice up your deviled eggs without resorting to hot peppers and other spicy ingredients? Try topping them with a smear of dijon mustard! Not only does this effortlessly bold flavor complement the different flavors in the deviled eggs perfectly, but it also adds an extra boost of protein to this already-healthy dish.

Tuna Salad

Another classic topping for potato salad, tuna salad makes an equally tasty addition to mayo or mustard-deviled eggs. This protein-rich ingredient can provide a hearty and satisfying texture to these bite-sized snacks while also helping to elevate their flavor profile. In addition, its light and fresh taste makes it an excellent choice for springtime celebrations like Easter or Mother's Day brunches!

Pesto Sauce

Finally, if you like to amp up the taste of your deviled eggs extraordinarily, consider adding pesto sauce as a topping. With fresh basil leaves as its base ingredient, this richly flavored green sauce can take your traditional deviled eggs from tasty to truly sensational in a straightforward step. The pesto adds that extra dose of green that helps make these egg-based goodies irresistible on any seasonal buffet table.


Whether preparing a simple barbecue or a lavish dinner party, deviled eggs are a tasty and versatile snack that everyone will enjoy. They can be made with various flavors and ingredients, from tangy mustard to creamy mayonnaise. To help you choose the best-deviled egg recipes for your needs, here are some great ads for mayo and mustard deviled eggs:

The Classic Mayo Deviled Eggs

This simple recipe combines classic mayonnaise with mustard, salt, and pepper for a delicious perfection. It is fast and comfortable to make and an excellent option for busy hosts who don't have time to pay for hours in the kitchen.

Creamy Mustard Deviled Eggs

Try this version with a combination of creamy mayo, grainy mustard, ground Cajun spices, and fresh diced pickles for something a little more sophisticated. Not just does it have lots of incredible flavors, but it also features fun textures, from crunchy pickles to creamy yolks.

Spicy Chipotle Mayo Deviled Eggs

Are you looking for something extra spicy? This recipe delivers with its fusion of tangy chipotle mayo, bold Dijon mustard, and plenty of hot paprika and dried red peppers. It is sure to get your guests' mouths watering!

Tangy Herb Mayo Deviled Eggs

If you want an elegant twist on traditional deviled eggs, try a delicious recipe incorporating herb-infused yogurt sauce combined with delicate honeydew melon chunks. Adding fresh herbs like dill, cilantro, or parsley is an easy way to enhance mayo eggs' flavor and nutritional value. It's perfect as an appetizer at fancy soirees or backyard barbecues alike.


Last but not least, you can transform plain old hard-boiled eggs into something unexpected by adding a dash of wasabi powder to them before serving. The intense heat from this Japanese cuisine staple packs a real punch that will wake up even the most jaded palate and have everyone coming back for more.

Choice Of Texture

There are countless ways you can handle your textural preferences when making hard boil eggs into appetizing dishes or snacks on the go. For instance, if you like creamy toppings, opt for something light like Greek yogurt mixed with dried dill. Alternatively, try diced tomatoes seasoned with basil and oregano if you prefer something chunky. Both make healthy additions that accompany hard-boiled eggs perfectly.

Additional Instructions

For perfect deviled eggs, be sure to follow the below instructions

  • Chill your hard-boiled eggs for at least an hour or overnight.
  • Slice the eggs in half and remove the yolk.
  • Beat yolks with a spoon until all crumbled.
  • Add mayonnaise, mustard, salt, and pepper to egg yolks and mix well.
  • Spoon egg yolk mixture into egg white.
  • Refrigerate until ready to serve.
  • Eat deviled eggs and enjoy

Final Verdict 

These delicious stuffed eggs are perfect for your next potluck or family gathering. They're super easy to make and only require a few ingredients you probably already have in your kitchen. Plus, you can customize multiple additional methods to fit your taste. So what are you waiting for? Get cooking! And if you need yummy recipes, be sure to check out Sauces by Jrk!

                                                                 KYLE PRICE 

Kyle Price, the creative force behind Sauces by Jrk!, brings a unique blend of Jamaican culinary heritage and modern flair to the world of gourmet sauces. Starting his journey in a bustling Miami kitchen, Kyle's passion for authentic Jamaican flavors and commitment to natural, health-focused ingredients quickly set his sauces apart. His mantra, "Health is Wealth, Mon," reflects in every bottle, offering a delicious journey into Jamaican tradition with a contemporary twist.

For more about Kyle and his approach, visit Sauces by Jrk!.